Oil Based vs. Water Based Lube: Condom Safety Explained Which lubricants are best for pain with penetrationwater vs silicone vs oil? The Womens Health Clinic If you're using condoms this Valentine's Day, your choice of lube matters more than you think. Did you know that oil based lubricants (like coconut oil, lotion, or baby oil) can actually weaken Surprise, surprise Oil based lube + condoms = Don't worry, there are alternatives: , 1Water based lube, 2Silicone lube, Other options that can cause condoms to break irritate genitals are Trojan Ultra Thin Plus Spermicide Latex Lubricated Condoms For Men Same Day Delivery Don Quijote